Saturday, November 17, 2007

Brent's Journey Has Ended

This is Brent's father writing at his request to report the conclusion of his journey with adult onset pleomorphic rhabdomyosarcoma, a rare and aggressive form of soft tissue cancer typically found in children, very rarely in adults. Brent passed away November 17th at the age of 46 years surrounded by his family at the home of his parents, John and Betty Zehr, Urbana, IL. A Celebration of Life Memorial Service will be held at 2:00 PM on Saturday, December 1st at the First Mennonite Church, 902 W. Springfield Ave., Urbana, Illinois. Since his last Blog, October 28th, Brent's health deteriorated rapidly making it impossible for him to post further messages.

Although Brent's initial Blog was in May 2007, his struggle with the disease began a year earlier. In the spring of 2006, while attending a research conference in Copenhagen, he first noticed a slight swelling at the eventual tumor site in his leg, assuming it was probably a hamstring injury and little knowing the lurking danger it posed. While struggling with this disease, he used this Blog site to openly share his thoughts, feelings and insights with the hope that others might find encouragement and comfort for their own personal journey, whatever that might be. As he neared the end of his life, Brent asked that, after he was gone, I write this post to announce his passing and later an additional final post to provide some details about the memorial service celebrating his life. He especially asked that these final posts be submitted as a way of bringing closure for those who have expressed their concerns during his difficult journey. Over the past months, Brent received cards, letters, phone calls, e-mails and Blog responses from individuals from both the US and around the world, some coming from individuals with whom he was simply acquainted, others with whom he had professional working relationships and yet others whom he had never met. For these, he was very grateful and encouraged that his posts had been an inspiration to others, many of whom also face their own difficult circumstances.

The majority of those reading his Blog knew very little about Brent other than information included in his posts. Therefore, without elaborating on the comments that appeared in his writings, I will provide a few details about his personal life: who he was, what he did and how he became the person most of you came to know only from his Blog posts.

Brent was quiet, unassuming and unpretentious, yet very bright. He was blessed with a mind of unusual perception and depth. At an early age it was apparent that he absorbed and processed information quickly and easily. As early as the second grade, his teachers remarked that "he thinks differently than the rest of the class." Throughout his grade school years, teachers often commented that he asked "what if" and "why" kinds of questions which were unusual for a child. Would not an event have turned out better if only someone had acted earlier? Why didn't someone do something about it before it was too late? He would ponder on new and different ways to deal with a situation that might have made a difference. Today, we call this "thinking outside the box." As a young child, Brent was "thinking outside the box" before the term was coined. He obtained an undergraduate degree at the University of Illinois, Champaign-Urbana, and went on to complete a PhD in Agronomy in June of 1990. His thesis research dealt with developing unique methods to identify genetic markers to be applied in maize breeding and, in general, applications to modify and enhance plant performance, particularly those related to improved food production. Along the way, he met and married an exceptionally gifted young woman from India, Usha Barwale, who also earned a PhD degree in a similar field. During the year prior to completion and defense of his doctoral dissertation, Brent was recruited to the teaching and research faculty of Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana. After completing his PhD, he and his family moved to Purdue where he lectured, supervised graduate student training and conducted plant research with corn. Usha also held a position as a plant research scientist during their time at Purdue. In the fall of 1996, he and Usha resigned their positions at Purdue and moved with their two sons, Benjamin and Brian, then aged three and seven, to India where Brent assumed the positon of Director of Research for the Maharashtra Hybrid Seed Company (Mahyco). There, he, assisted by Usha, led teams of research scientists in the development and application of modern genetic and biotechnology techniques. Over the past decade, their work has resulted in significant improvements in an array of hybrid varieties of food, fiber and edible oil crops, all of which has enhanced the welfare of countless small farmers and their families in India and has implications for others throughout the world. Until the final weeks of his life, Brent was in conversation by e-mail with his colleagues and staff in India making comments on the results of work they had sent for his review and suggesting future avenues to pursue.

From his earliest years, Brent was an avid and skilled fisherman, much more so than his two brothers and only sister. Since I (his father) was also a fishing enthusiast, over the years we tested the waters of Illinois, Missouri, Wisconsin and Minnesota. We fished several years at a remote Canadian lake accessible only by fly-in pontoon planes. We fished at isolated lakes of the high country of British Columbia, in streams of the Cascade Mountains and the wider Pacific Ocean. We once spent a half-day off the coast of Hawaii hoping to catch a Marlin, without success. While he was an early teenager, Brent and I spent two weeks canoeing, fishing and camping in the Canadian wilderness, seeing no one and in complete isolation for the entire period. Later, as a college student, he led groups of students and adults on canoe and camping trips to the Canadian boundary waters. To the very end, he never lost the urge to get away for a time to some remote area to go fishing. In fact, during his final appointment at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota, upon learning from sarcoma specialists that the new monoclonal antibody experimental treatments, of which he was a subject, were unsuccessful and that there was no known treatment for his rare type of cancer and that his life would soon be ending, he called and asked if I could come and join him for one last trip to Bowstring Lake, a beautiful spot in northern Minnesota where, with his two sons, we had spent time fishing for a number of years. Regrettably, his health and energy had deteriorated to such an extent that it was not possible for us to make that "last trip to Bowstring". Rather than spending his final days in a hospital undergoing further, and undoubtedly futile, efforts to temporarily prolong his life, he and Usha made the difficult decision to return to the home of his parents to live out his final days surrounded by his immediate family while under the care of a Hospice nurse. His final weeks were marked by numerous visits from family members, from friends and other acquaintances and from professional colleagues, both from the US and abroad. Those visits were deeply appreciated and brought closure to some very meaningful professional and personal relationships.

A Final Farewell to Brent:

Brent, we were privileged and honored that you were a member of our family. Even though you left us much too soon, you had an exceptionally full and productive life. You married a spectacularly gifted wife (Usha) who has given you two fine sons. You traveled the world on research and business matters, as well as for recreational activities with your family. You were comfortable and worked effectively in both Eastern and Western cultures. You met and worked with a wide range of interesting people, from small underprivileged Indian farmers, to politicians, to academicians and Noble Prize winners. You were an outstanding research scientist whose contributions in modern plant biotechnology had a positive impact on the economic welfare of those who aspire for a better life for their families. For years to come, the results of your work will continue to influence the lives of many around the world. You were an effective administrator having gifts for the leadership required for team building to identify and develop new research initiatives and to transfer that research from the laboratory to the fields. Furthermore, as your life neared its end, your Blog posts left a lasting impact on many people, most of whom remain unknown to you. You shared your thoughts about the uncertainties of life and how one accepts the certainty of an approaching death. The raw honesty and courage with which you wrote were a continuation of the integrity you demonstrated throughout your life and the world is better because you were a part of it. Your pain has now ended and you are in a far better place. Someone has suggested that God's greatest gift to us is death because it opens the path to restoration. Brent you have now received God's final and greatest gift - - the path to restoration. With Usha's excellent nurturing skills and dedication to your family, you may rest assured that your young sons, Benjamin and Brian, will be well cared for and will grow to be a credit and honor to your legacy. While they will never fully understand the tragedy in their lives of the loss of their father and best friend, during your final weeks you spent much time and counseled them extensively about your impending death and how their lives would be affected thereafter. All of which has softened their pain and provided them with wisdom of which they would otherwise have been deprived. For this, they will be forever grateful.

Surely, there must be a place in heaven:
- where crystal clear lakes are surrounded by green forests,
- where loons cry their lonesome calls in the night,
- where walleye and northerns and muskie and bass await to play their pesky games with those trying to catch them,
- where a mallard duck swims quietly across the glassy water followed single-file by her little brood. Together, they leave a V-shaped wake, almost as if a playful God had dipped a finger in the water to create a trace across the glassy surface.

And as the early morning dawn announces a new day and the sun begins to rise over the evergreens of the surrounding forests, a bald eagle soars high overhead.

Then you will know that surely this must be a part of heaven. If not, then these are places where heaven has come down to touch the earth.

We know this for certain, Brent -- because, together, we have often watched the early morning sun rise on places such as this. Surely, God was there. So this, too, must be a part of heaven.

Farewell for now, Brent. You have gone on before us, but we will meet you at the place where there is no more pain, no more sarcomas, no more anger, no more conflict - - - only peace and praise for the One to whom we have committed our lives.

Your Dad, Mother and Family

Addendum: At Brent's request, I will submit a final Blog entry outlining something of the memorial service celebrating his life. Also, prior to his passing, in response to a number of requests, Brent asked that his Blog posts be compiled into a book for those who might be interested. To request a copy, e-mail me at:
Zjbz@aol.com. Please identify your request on the subject line as: Brent' Journey. This will be helpful in sorting out those requests from routine junk mail. Pease provide a name and mailing address.

18 comments:

Siva said...

What a sad end...I pray for your soul to rest in peace Brent. May all what you dreamt about, come true.

Siva

Balasubramanian said...

Dear Brent: What a great loss to us! I always cherish those moments when we first met at Coimbatore. My hearty condolences to Usha and the kids, who were so hospitable when I visited your Jalgoan Residence.

May all your dreams come to fruition!

Bala

Bob Hudson said...

Yesterday was a beautiful day here in Urbana, IL and before hearing of Brent's death, I got the urge to go canoeing. So my son Soren and I headed out to Kickapoo State Park, located about 30 miles east of Urbana. The views from the water were beautiful, with the leaves off nearly all of the trees, except for the odd cypress and a few other stragglers. The afternoon sunshine reflecting off the lake into our eyes was invigorating. We saw a number of Canadian geese and other birds and a lone fish jumping. Most remarkable was that we saw two pairs of swans, a species that I haven't seen around here often. As we paddled, I recalled conversations that I'd had with Brent about canoeing (I'm a recent convert to this sport). What brought me the most joy was how moved Soren was by the beauty of the day.

When we got home and learned that Brent had died while we were out on the water, the day seemed to take on the feeling of poetry, full of images and symbols tinged with both beauty and real sadness. After reading in John's post today how meaningful canoeing was to Brent and John, this poetic sense of the day seemed confirmed. The swans had stuck with me as an important symbol within the poem, so I was moved to learn that:

Swans are revered in many religions and cultures, especially Hinduism. ... persons who have attained great spiritual capabilities are sometimes called Paramahamsa ("Great Swan") on account of their spiritual grace and ability to travel between various spiritual worlds. (Wikipedia)

I hope I cause no offense to Brent's Christian faith nor his many Hindu friends if I suggest that to me, in sharing about his struggle with cancer and his spiritual growth through it, Brent showed the spiritual grace of such a swan.

I came very close to losing my father to a serious illness when I was 13 (he recovered but not to full health), so I've had a very personal reason to feel moved by Brent's journey and be impressed with the kind of father he's been to his own sons. Thank you and God's peace. You have earned your rest.

Harold said...

My dear Mr & Mrs Zehr, Usha, Brian n Benjamin,
Harry n I offer you our deepest sympathy and heartfelt condolence over your irreparable loss. Though we are keenly aware of the futility of words in cosoling or comforting you, being so far away we can only express our sincere feelings in words. We have been with each of you in prayer all through these difficult months of anguish and pain. While I tried all the "never fail" prayers and Novenas to plead for a miracle to cure our precious Brent, I slowly realized that God had His own plans for Brent. A gardener knows when to pluck his fruit - always at its prime and God has taken Brent when his soul was most pleasing to Him. His stoic acceptance of all his sufferings must have gained him direct entry into Paradise. Not a single day has gone by without a fervent prayer for Brent. Now we assure you of our prayers for each of you. We know the void he leaves can never be filled. We know that you will miss his smile, his voice, his counsel but we are sure God will give you courage and strength in this hour of sorrow. The Church offers us consolation with the words "In death life is changed, not taken away". Yes indeed Brent will continue to be "close" to each of you.
Our priest son will offer a Requiem Mass for Brent tomorrow. We sent supplications up at our morning mass today. I will request all our priest friends to pray for the repose of Brent's soul.
We will be with you in spirit on Saturday,2nd Dec during the service. Yes it's a celebration of a Life well lived. Brent taught us so much, most of all he reminded us that life is a journey to God. Very often we behave as though we are permanent residents on earth though the first Catechism lesson taught "God made us to know Him, to love Him in this world and to be happy with Him forever in the next!" Brent has undoubtedly won his reward of unalloyed bliss with his Creator. I would like to share with you a poem composed by Tennyson when he was in the 81st year. It was his desire that it be sung at his death. It expresses Brent's feeling so well I can't resist sending it to you.

CROSSING THE BAR

Sunset and evening star,
And one clear call for me!
And may there be no meaning of the bar
When I put out to sea.

But such a tide as moving seems asleep
Too full for sound and foam
When that which drew from out the boundless deep
Turns again home.

Twilight and evening bell,
And after that the dark!
And may there be no sadness of farewell,
When I embark.

For tho' from out our bourne of Time and Place
The flood may bear me far.
I hope to see my Pilot face to face
When I have crost the bar.

Brent is just on the opposite shore but freed from pain and suffering.
Harry and I share your grief. They say sorrows shared are halved. Well Brent's numerous friends and admirers will surely lighten your heavy hearts. We continue to pray for each of you by name everyday at Mass.
Yours in grief,
Marjorie

Unknown said...

Dear Sir,
Its a very sad for all of us.
May your soul rest in peace. May all your dreams come true.

Dinesh said...

Very unfortunate and sad end of an intellectual, caring and pleasing personality. All those who got an opportunity to interact with Brent in their professional and personal association will miss him always. He was full of ideas and professionally very strong. I cherish those moments whenever I interacted and held discussions with him. My heartfelt condolence to the family. I pray God to help Usha and the family to fulfil Brent's dreams and unfulfilled desires!

Dinesh

pprashant said...

Everyone's journey has to end one day. I think it was so early for Brent. He should have done a lot of good for Indian Agriculture with Mahyco.

I pray for his soul to rest in peace.

His Blog was really an inspiration for the courage shown to fight the disease.

Prashant Pathak
Mumbai, India

pprashant said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Steven Swartzendruber said...

To the Zehr family, my condolences. It's been probably 30+ years since Brent and I went to Sunday school classes together, but I remember his intelligence and sweet manner. Only today I learned of Brent's illness and passing and my thoughts go out to all of you. Peace.

Steven Swartzendruber

Unknown said...

Dear Usha, Brian and Ben,

We are deeply sadden to learn about Brent has passed away and our sincere condolence to all three of you and the rest of the family. Our thoughts and prayers are with you and your family at this difficult moment.

Brent, you were a good human with kind heart driven by a true passion in whatever you did in your life. You will be remembered by your good deeds by many people in India as well as in the USA. I would cherish all the time I spent at Mahyco with you and our phone conversations later in your life. We want to let you know that we will be there for Usha and your children today and forever. We miss you forever and it is a great loss for your family and many of us.

May God bless everyone in your family.

With love and Prayers,
Kasi and Sridevi

vrdakshinamurthy said...

Though the event was not unexpected in the circumstances as it evolved over the last year,it does leave a void difficult to fill.

Those whom God loves die young.

If Almighty decides that the purpose of Brent's Mortal exitence has been completed, He recalls to His immortal home.

I pray to GOD that He give all your family members the strength and courage to face this reality and challenge with equanimity.

Unknown said...

Dear Brent,

After getting the news that you have left for your heavenly abode, it seemed that with the enlightenment that is yours now, the words of care and affection, would look childlike to you. But then, it occurred that the communication must conclude logically. I am writing this, just for you dear brave friend, because I know, you are going to read it. It is easy to picture a smile on your face, that is so serene now, without the minutest trace of the pain that had engulfed you towards the last few months on this planet.

Now you see the Sun’s disk, but the heat is not scorching, rather it is embalming. Now you travel through the luminosity of the full moon and find it is healing, therapeutic. So many truths are revealed to you. That you were here for a purpose. That you have been taken away for a purpose. That He has walked the path with you, been with you, with every step that you took on the Earth.

The wise say, you will not win the Beloved’s heart, unless you lose your own. You have done that. That’s why, rarely has a person, in his lifetime received the loads of praises and prayers, that you have. Across continents. Across cultures.

You are now in attendance in the Divine court. He sprinkled glorious light upon you and you are essentially one with him now. Rest there, enveloped with the joy of His love, drink out of the endless fountain of His benevolence. Find your peace.

Amen.

Yours sincerely,
Shobha and Chiranjeev Prasad,
Jalna (India).

Rex Bernardo said...

Dear Usha, Brian, and Benjamin:

May "The LORD bless you and keep you; the LORD make his face shine upon you and be gracious to you; the LORD turn his face toward you and give you peace." (Numbers 6:24-26).

Sincerely,

Rex Bernardo

Unknown said...

A fighter till the end I must say.. Salute to such a great soul. may all that you dreamt to do come true at the hands of your wife and sons.
May Your Soul Rest In Peace.. Adieu

Unknown said...

Dear Ushaji,

We are deeply sadden to learn about untimely dimise of Brent and our sincere condolence to all family members. Our sincere prayers are with you and your family at this difficult moment.

Brent's untime dimise is grate loss to entire farming community of India. Brent was a good human with kind heart,caring and pleasing personality. I cherish those moments whenever I interacted and exchanged ideas with him. We will try to fulfil Brent's dreams.
May God give courage to all of us to bear this loss and to achieve his dreams.
Kamal Somani

Unknown said...

It's an unbelievable and unconvincing loss to the family and entire scientific community. God's will is very unchoosy and cruel once gain. I immensely wish and pray for Usha Madam and children for their speedy reversal to normal and active life.

ELANGOVAN M said...

Dear Dr.Brent,

May your soul rest in peace, You have accomplished the purpose of your life.

Elan

Unknown said...

Dear Dr Usha,
My heart felt condolences. I strongly believe that you can carry Brent's Legacy further, further and further..

Sincerely,
Netaji